"It is not the great temptations that ruin us; it is the little ones."
John W. DeForest
Nutrition 911, Part IV: Sweeteners
Plus, 5 ways to satisfy your sweet tooth!
By Steve Edwards
Part IV of our oh-so-basic nutrition class designed to give you an overview of
basic nutrition and make healthy eating much simpler. In Part
I, we addressed the terms organic, grass-fed, free-range, and farm-raised. Part
II analyzed the ever-popular "fat-free" and trendy "low-carb" slogans. In Part
III, we took the CliffsNotes approach to reading
food labels. Now it's time for dessert. Let's discuss some options for giving
in to your sweet tooth.
lesson will be broken into three parts. First, we'll look at sugar and why you
want to limit the amount you eat. Next, we'll quickly examine artificial
sweeteners. Finally, we'll talk about healthy ways to curb your cravings.
class is the ultra basics, so instead of using words like saccharide and galactose, let's just say that sugar is the
simplest form of carbohydrates. It's sweet, yummy, and easy to crave. In
nature, it's found in plants. As you recall from Part 1, plants have fiber and
this minimizes sugar's impact on your system by causing it to be digested
slowly. Carbohydrates, whether from potatoes, lettuce, or Oreos, all break down
into sugars in your body, and you use these sugars as fuel when you do stuff.
So, if done right, eating carbohydrates is a good thing, especially when you're
sugar, the white grainy stuff you'll find in gummy bears, chocolate, Coke, and
most desserts, is sugar minus the fiber that surrounded it in nature. What you're
left with is a sweet but highly caloric food that your body absorbs very
rapidly, causing a "sugar rush." This "rush" is a temporary
imbalance in your system that your body tries to regulatea spike of energy
followed by a lull.
body hates the lull, so to bring you back up, it'll crave, you guessed it, more
sugar. It's an ugly cycle considering refined sugar's
only nutritional value is similar to a nitrous injection in a race cara quick
burst of energy that burns right out. This might be a good thing if you're in a
drag race (or, in human terms, if you need an extra burst of energy in a
workout), but it's a bad thing any other time because if you don't put that
excess sugar to use, it gets stored as fat.
Bottom line: Refined
sugar is okay for sports performance (while you are skiing, bicycling, running,
and so on), but bad at all other times. Therefore, straight sugar consumption
should be limited.
probably wondering, "So the best time to eat gummy bears would be during a
marathon instead of at night in front of the TV?" The answer is yes,
And now you're
probably thinking, "But I want dessert after dinner!"
all do. Something sweet after a meal, while habitual, is pretty darn ingrained
in our society. So now that we understand that sugar should be limited, let's
look at some ways to do it.
I'm not going to do a breakdown of the artificial sweeteners on the
marketbecause we already have. I recommend that you read "The
Sweet and Low Down," which will only take you a couple of minutes.
Essentially, there are a bunch of different artificial sweeteners to choose
from. Most are made of various chemical reactions that your taste buds think
are sweet but aren't used by your body and, hence, have zero calories.
also some, called sugar alcohols, which have fewer calories than regular sugar
because they've been combined with an artificial fiber that you can't digest.
These have "tol" at the end of their names,
One, Stevia or "sweet leaf," is natural. It's
basically a, well, sweet leaf that you can chew on or that we can grind into a
powder, like sugar.
Now you might
be thinking, "This all sounds great! What's the catch?"
The catch is
that they may not be safe. The FDA has approved somebut given their track
record lately (Vioxx, etc.), we can easilyand
shouldbe a bit skeptical. With a cursory search of the Internet, you can find
both pro and con studies of each alternative sweetener. The FDA is highly
influenced by lobbyists and does not accept all viable studies, meaning that
you might want more than FDA approval before blindly trusting what you put into
So let's use
some logic to try to assess how best to choose a sweetener. By adding two and
two together, we should be able stack the odds in our favor.
- Time. Saccharin is the most maligned of
this bunch, yet it's been around more than 100 years and is still on the
market. Sure, there is some negative research out there, but it can't be that bad! A lot of people consume a lot of different artificial sweeteners. If
people were dropping like flies, we'd probably hear about it.
- Research. If one of these sweeteners were so
good, why would other people keep trying to come up with better ones? From this
fact alone, we know that at least some of those negative findings must have an
inkling of merit.
- Money. The influence of big business can
keep need-to-know information from the public (again, Vioxx,
- Artificial or natural? "Artificial" sounds bad,
and "natural" sounds good. But just because something is natural does
not mean it's good. Tobacco and opium are natural. So the claim that Stevia is good because "it's natural" bears
little relevance. Many very beneficial drugs are artificial. However, you
generally don't want to take them habitually, which is how some people use
artificial sweeteners. Artificial doesn't mean bad, but it should mean caution.
- Anecdotal. I'm going to share two quick
- First, my sister is a sweet leaf proponent. It's
time honored and natural, but lacks FDA approval. She lobbied Starbucks for a
natural alternative to Splenda (chlorinated sugar).
She got a long line of positive responses up the chain of command until, finally, they stopped returning her calls. A short
time later, her local market (a chain that she used as an example for
Starbucks) was forced to stop offering sweet leaf with their coffee and only
sell it as a "supplement." Coincidence or a blatant case of big
business (Starbucks and/or the folks who bring you Splenda)
using strong-arm tactics against someone who truly cares about your health? In
the wake of the FDA scandal, it's hard not to at least harbor a little
is a female athlete that I trained who could not lose weight, despite being in
great shape and eating a strict diet. Her vice was about 100 ounces of no-cal
soft drinks per day. She would eye double Big Gulps like a junky does crack.
When we were able to get her off the stuffshe even drank some sugared soft
drinks to do soshe lost 15 pounds. Now, I'll say this had more to do with all
the phosphorus and her body's pH balance but, still, who really knows what all
those chemicals are doing in your system?
Bottom line: There is no hard evidence that any one sweetener is better than the
others. Most likely, this stuff won't kill you. But given we also know it's not
100% safe, it would seem wise to limit your consumption as much as possible.
5 Ways to Satisfy Your Sweet Tooth
We're about out of time, so let's get to it. Here are
my five favorite ways to cut down sugar consumption without ruining all of your
- Portion control. I recently saw a sign in a Denny's window saying "Remember, an
apple a day" on a dessert that was an apple surrounded by about 2,000
calories of sugar and fat. Our society has gone crazy for "bigger is
better." After dinner, your body is not hungry. You don't need 2,000 extra
calories. You don't need 200! If you savor a square of chocolate of a
tablespoon of Ben & Jerry's slowly, it will curb your cravings without a
noticeable effect on your diet.
- Don't snack on artificial sweeteners. Gum is probably the worst snack because it creates a
stimulus-response action that causes you to crave sweet stuff constantly.
- Add some fruit to your sugar or artificial sweetener. Fruit is both sweet and good for
you. However, I realize an apple might not be enough all by itself to satiate
your sweet tooth. But you can dress up fruit with a very small amount of "real"
dessert and make it pretty darn decadent.
- Make sure
you have some complex carbs in your diet. This
sounds boring but complex carbs, like whole grains,
sweet potatoes, rice, beans n' stuff, all slowly break down into blood sugar.
If your blood sugar is steady, you won't crave sugar. You might still
habitually crave it, but that's a ton better than a sugar crash craving, which
will likely lead to bingeing.
protein powder trick. Most protein powders have a small amount of sugar, a
touch of artificial sweetener, and are 90% protein. If you can find one you
like (ours is fantastic, ahem, ahem), you might be able to curb your cravings
with a high-protein snack. Chalene Johnson, the
creator of Turbo Jam, uses chocolate protein powder as a base for pudding and
Beachbody Advice Staff Denis Faye sprinkles it on cereal. If you get creative,
the possibilities may be endless!
Back to top.
20 Treats That Taste NaughtyBut They're Not!
By Monica Ciociola
working out regularly and doing your best to eat healthy, it's okay to indulge
your sugar fantasies every once in awhile. So I asked the ladies at Beachbody
to share their secrets for satisfying their sugar fixes without breaking the
scale. Here's the list of 20 snacks and desserts
that made the cut, and I promise you won't find those sawdusty caramel-flavored rice cakes anywhere on it!
- Anna, Beachbody's Success Story Manager, admits she doesn't have much of a sweet tooth, but loves
this frosty and refreshing treat she saw on the Food Network, the only channel
she ever watches:
- Italian granita. 2 cups of espresso coffee, cooled,
with Splenda to taste. Pour coffee into an 8x10
baking pan and pop it in the freezer. Important: Every half hour take a fork and scrape the freezing coffee to
avoid a solid block. When frosty, and crystals have formed, scoop into a fancy
glass and enjoy this little pick-me-up!
- Lara, who's
runway-model thin, but unlike Anna, has a serious sweet tooth, has found a way
to have her cake and eat it, too. Here are her favorites:
- Chocolate delight. 1/2 cup nonfat chocolate frozen yogurt topped with
2 Tbsp. Cool Whip, and 1 Tbsp. chopped almonds.
- Strawberry parfait. 1/2 cup sliced strawberries and 1/2 cup
nonfat yogurt mixed together and sprinkled with cinnamon.
- Healthy surprise. Puree 1/2 cup nonfat cottage cheese, Splenda, and cinnamon. Top with 1 Tbsp. chopped
nuts, and serve with 1/2 cup sliced apple.
- Strawberry sorbet. Mix 1 cup frozen strawberries and 1 Tbsp. sugar.
Let sit for a few hours. Add lemon juice and puree in blender. Put in
freezer until ready to eat!
- Banana split. Slice 1/2 banana, top with 1/2 cup low-fat ice cream
or yogurt, and sprinkle with 1 Tbsp. chopped nuts and 1 Tbsp. melted dark
- Cinnamon bread. Take 1 slice lite cinnamon toast, spread with 1 Tbsp. lite butter,
and sprinkle with Equal and cinnamon.
- Peanut butter treat. Take 1 slice lite toast or 2 Wasa crisps
and top with 1 Tbsp. peanut butter and 1 Tbsp. honey.
- Chocolate-covered strawberries. Dip 4 large strawberries in 2
Tbsp. melted dark chocolate.
- Frozen coffee treat. Fill large cup with ice, pour cold coffee, add Splenda and 1/4 cup nonfat milk and whip in a
- Yogurt swirl. Mix 1 cup nonfat yogurt with 1/2 cup unsweetened
- Not-so-naughty s'mores. Dip 3 graham crackers in
3 Tbsp. fat-free Cool Whip topping, and drizzle with 1 Tbsp. melted dark
- Jude likes to spend weekends running
and hiking for hours on end, but as you can see, still tries to keep her treats
as guilt-free as possible:
- Air-popped or stovetop popcorn. Sprinkle
with a little low-fat Parmesan cheese, chili powder, or Mrs. Dashnever
butter or salt!
- JELL-O® with fruit. Make your favorite flavor of
JELL-O, but before it completely sets, stir in sliced bananas or
strawberries, blueberries, pineapple chunks, or a can of drained fruit
- Frozen yogurt fruit pops. Blend
1 cup fat-free yogurt (any flavor) with 2 Tbsp. honey and 1 cup fruit,
then spoon into popsicle molds and freeze.
- Baked apple. Core apple and stuff
with 1 Tbsp. raisins, 1/4 tsp. cinnamon, and 1/2 tsp. honey. Wrap in
plastic wrap and microwave for 2 minutes. Turn apple and microwave again
for 1 minute. Repeat until apple is cooked.
- Recovery smoothie. Blend 2 scoops P90X Peak Recovery Formula with 12 oz. water, a
handful of ice cubes, and a banana. Creamy and delicious!
- I'm a certified
chocoholic whose day isn't complete without chocolate (and I don't like to cook). Here are three
of my favorite grocery-store discoveries (just don't eat the whole box!):
- JELL-O® Sugar-Free Chocolate Pudding
Snacks. Sugar-free chocolate swirl treats that actually taste, well, rich, creamy,
and chocolately. I can't believe they're only 60
calories per cup! Add sliced bananas for more nutrients, luxurious
texture, and an even more delightfully satisfying snack.
- Popsicle® Mini Ice Cream Sandwiches. Snack-sized sandwiches with
creamy vanilla ice cream in between two chocolate wafers. Low-fat, 10%
calcium, and only 90 calories, they're too good to pass up!
- Healthy Choice Healthy Choice® Premium Ice Cream Bars. Low-fat vanilla ice cream
dipped in heavenly fudge, they're only 80 calories a pop, so enjoy!
Back to top.